REPORT BACK FROM THE RIC-EDINBURGH
EU DEBATE ON THURSDAY 4TH FEB,
IN THE AUGUSTINE CHURCH
Two of the original billed speakers Professor Jo Shaw (non-aligned)
and Neil Davidson( RS21) both gave their apologies. Alistair Black (RISE), Donny Gluckstein (SWP) and
Dr. Myrto Tsakatika (Syriza-Scotland) put forward the arguments for and against
leaving the EU. Sally Wainwright RIC
chaired the meeting. 50 people attended. After the introductions the meeting
was then organised into break-out groups. Instead of time-consuming report-backs
from all the groups, each was asked to produce post-its of the points it wanted
raised, either as questions or contributions. Below is a compilation of all
these points. These will be circulated throughout RIC.
There will be a further opportunity to discuss the issue at
the forthcoming national RIC conference in Edinburgh on Saturday 20th February
(see http://radical.scot)
published on
RIC-Edinburgh blog at:- http://radicalindyedinburgh.blogspot.co.uk/2016/02/report-back-from-ric-edinburgh-eu_13.html
QUESTIONS COMING FROM THE BREAK-OUT GROUPS
1. Where can we
get accurate information about the EU?
2. How do we
bring more people into the discussion?
3. Is leaving
the EU a question of principle or tactics?
4. Would the UK
be better off out of the EU?
5. How does EU
policy actually limit British law/action? What are the economicand worker right advantages/disdvantages
of being in the EU?
6. How much
could we change the EU without leaving?
7. What would
the UK look like out of the EU?
8. What would
the EU look like without the UK?
9. What are the
economic and political forces behind staying in and leaving?
10. How would
migrant workers be better off if the EU left the EU?
11. Will there be
an amnesty for EU citizens currently in the UK if there is out of the EU?
12. If there is a
'Leave' vote what happens to UK citizens living in Europe?
13. Would we take
in more refugees if there was a 'Remain' a 'Leave' vote?
14. What would
happen the day after a 'Leave' vote?
15. A number of
groups associated with the protection of the environment have said that the UK leaving the EU would
have a detrimental effect. So what do people
feel about this?
16. What does the
Left in the rest of the EU say about whether the UK should leave?
17. Would a 'Leave'
vote it encourage other countries you leave?
18. Can we
harness the optimism of Syria?
19. How much
potential is there for pan-European worker cooperation?
20. Should we be
taking into account other trends, such as the rise of Bernie Sanders (US) and Jeremy Corbyn?
21. Are we
heading for another banking crisis and if so how does that affect things?
22. Is it easier
to fight from inside or outside the EU?
23. Is it easier
to fight the Tories than the Tories and EU?
24. Is Scotland
more pro-EU?
25. What happens
if Scotland votes to stay and England votes to leave?
26. Would getting
a 'Remain' vote a second Scottish independence be more difficult if the whole of the UK is outside the EU?
27. How long
would it take to complete Brexit and what effect would a prolonged negotiating period have on UK politics?
28. Would the EU
bureaucracy recognise a Brexit vote or would it push for a rerun, like it did with Ireland over
Maastricht?
29. Why am I
still confused?!
CONTRIBUTIONS MADE IN THE BREAK OUT GROUPS
GENERAL POINTS
1. The
referendum opens up a new political option with greater turnout and interest in politics, where the Left could be
influential in the debate.
2. We need a
non-party campaign.
3. We need
country wide political educational programme - popular education.
4. The economic
forces behind Brexit are mainly small businesses, which fear EU competition and have no clout
within the EU.
5. The main
economic force for staying in are those larger businesses with markets in the EU and which can have
influence on the EU through lobbying etc..
6. The banks
look more split. Some favour the wider market in finance, others fear EU regulation and are turning
East (e.g. China).
7. The Tory
Right and UKIP are currently the main forces behind Brexit. They want the UK as an offshore economy able
to undercut the EU, and with much fewer
migrant workers, and not subject to any progressive EU legislation.
8. The Far
Right, the BNP, EDL, SDL, WDL and the Ulster Loyalists want Brexit.
9. Cameron and
his Tory backers are the main force for staying in a renegotiated EU, with fewer rights for immigrants and
a further weakening of the Social Chapter.
10. The Blairite
wing of the Labour Party and the Lib-Dems want to remain in the EU. They could form a 'Better Together' Mark
2 with Cameron.
11. Corbyn used
to be an abstentionist, but under pressure from the Blairites has become more pro-EU.
12. The SNP is
for a 'Remain' vote, believing the EU benefits Scotland and that Scotland needs more migrant because
of an ageing population.
13. A section of
the 45%ers also want a 'Remain vote in Scotland, but a 'Leave' vote in England to precipitate a second independence referendum.
14. Jim Sillars,
Jim Fairlie and the ultra-Nats want a 'Leave' vote.
ARGUMENTS RELEVANT TO
'REMAIN', LEAVE' OR ABSTAIN
1. We need to
join with the people of Europe to challenge the big institutions of capitalism.
2. Don't just
focus on the institutions it is about movements.
3. The real
issue is building collective resistance. Greece would have been broken by big capital whether it was in or
out of the EU.
4. Separate the
legitimate demands for a borderless Europe from the EU as an institution.
5. The main
forces behind the official pro-EU campaign and behind Brexit are both pro-TTIP.
6. We need a
vision of a socialist Europe.
7. Cameron's
decision to not allow the 1.5million EU residents the vote, shows who the Tories are targeting (c.f. the
Scottish independence referendum where EU
residents had the vote).
'REMAIN' ARGUMENTS
1. History of
peace in Europe since EU formed is important.
2. The free
movement of labour has brought about greater multiculturalism and more vibrant culture.
3. We should
remain for tax justice: EU gives us bank bonus tax. There is an ongoing discussion on a Financial
Transaction Tax, and another on EU wider Corporation
Tax'.
4. The Right
want greater freedom undermine democratic rights and what's left of the EU's Social Chapter.
5. Environmental
regulation to be successful needs to operate across the EU.
6. Victory for
Brexit would mean more racism weakening the working class
7. It is the UK
not the EU which is putting up barriers at Calais.
8. It would be
the Right and the Far Right who would be celebrating on the streets the day after a 'Brexit' vote, just
as they were on September 19th after
the 'No' to independence vote.
9. Brexit would
lead to the reappearance of border posts between north and south of
Ireland, strengthening reaction, particularly the Loyalists.
10. It is the
Right and the Far Right that form the majority wanting to leave the EU in most member countries.
11. Varoufakis
(Syriza ex-Finance Minister) is organising the Democracy in Europe 2025 Movement to unite opposition
across the EU.
'LEAVE' ARGUMENTS
1. The EU is an
anti-democratic bosses' club.
2. The free
movement of labour has led to lower pay and worse conditions in some sections of the economy, e.g.
agriculture.
3. The Common
Agricultural Policy mainly benefits rich farmers, is environmentally disastrous and leads to dumping in Third World
countries at the cost of poor
peasants.
4. The EU did
not stop the war in Bosnia or Kosova.
5. The EU did
not stop civil war in Northern Ireland or Euskadi.
6. The EU's
Schengen Agreement is directed against migrants from the rest of the world.
6. The EU is
renewing internal borders to stop migrants.
7. Germany's
treatment of Greece shows that the EU is an alliance for economic purposes, not for justice.
8. The
humiliation of Syriza shows that the Left can not adopt a pro-EU stance.
9. The position
of migrants is not dependent on EU, Norway and Switzerland have bigger proportion of migrants
than many EU members.
10. The position
of workers not dependent on EU agreements but collective organisation of workers.
11. The Let needs
to form its own Brexit campaign.
Other articles on
RISE-Edinburgh blog relevant to the EU debate
THE CURRENT SITUATION
IN GREECE - KIMON BUKAS (ANTARSAYA)
THE EU REFERENDUM -
DEBATE BETWEEN ALLAN ARMSTRONG RCN AND DONNY GLUCKSTEIN SWP
